November 10, 2017 | personal injury Claims
Pre-Existing Health Conditions and Toronto Injury Claims
Table of Contents
You do not have to voluntarily disclose your pre-existing conditions to the insurance company. If the insurance company is asking for access to your medical records, talk to your lawyer. A lawyer in Toronto can evaluate what you should share and can manage communications with the insurer on your behalf.
Be aware, though, that just because you have a preexisting medical condition, such as a bad back or even a previously unknown degenerative condition, it does not mean you cannot recover compensation for your injuries. Even if you aggravated a preexisting condition, you may still recover compensation for your new injuries.
Risks Of Sharing Too Much Information
An individual should never lie to an insurance company, and concealing medical information related to the injury may seriously hurt an individual’s claim. However, an individual is not obligated to voluntarily disclose all of their medical information to the insurance company. The insurance company is entitled to medical records related to an individual’s injuries, but they do not have to share their entire medical history.
Never give a recorded statement to the insurance company or agree to sign any documents, including a medical release form, without first asking a lawyer to review them. If the insurance company makes repeated or vexatious requests for an individual’s records, they should direct them to their lawyer.
Preexisting Conditions Do Not Bar From Compensation
An unrelated preexisting condition should have no effect on an individual’s current injury claim. For example, if someone suffered a neck injury five years ago and their most recent accident caused fractures in their lower extremities, their previous neck injury should have no effect on their current claim.
If an individual’s preexisting condition is related to their new injuries, it may affect their claim, but it does not bar them from recovering compensation. For example, if an individual’s most recent accident aggravated their old neck injury, they can still recover compensation for the aggravation and worsening of their old injury.
Before an individual accepts an insurance company’s settlement offer, they should review their case with a lawyer to better understand if and how their preexisting condition may affect their current injury claim. A lawyer will make sure they have the supporting medical evidence to prove the existence of any injuries and the value of the claim for such injuries.
Contact A Lawyer
Insurance companies may take various positions in order to reduce your settlement or deny your claim altogether. A common position taken by insurers may be to blame injuries from your recent accident on a preexisting condition.
Never let the insurance company force you into accepting a settlement, and do not agree to any settlement offer without having a lawyer review it first. A lawyer will deal with the insurance company and help you collect the medical evidence you need to prove your injuries are not preexisting or that your current injuries worsened your preexisting injuries.
Blog Categories
More personal injury Topics
Here’s more information on personal injury related topics that we think you might find helpful.

accident benefits
|
December 24, 2025
Ontario Tort Claims Explained: What They Are and How They Work
Tort claims are one of the most common ways injured people in Ontario seek compensation after an accident. While negligence claims make up the majority…

personal injury
|
November 13, 2025
Pain and Suffering Damages Calculator for Ontario (2025): Thresholds and Deductible Explained
In Ontario, pain and suffering damages (also known as non-pecuniary or general damages) compensate for human losses that don’t appear on a tangible bill. For…

personal injury
|
January 23, 2024
Injured as a Worker in Ontario? A WSIB Claim Isn’t Necessarily Your Best— Or Only— Option
In Ontario, the compensation of workers who sustain injuries or illnesses in the course of their employment is governed by the Workplace Safety and Insurance…
Speak With Our
Legal Team for FREE
Find Out if You Have a Case in Under 5 Minutes
Speak to a Lawyer Now!
We’re here to help.

